Saturday, February 11, 2006

A New Paradigm ?

While Bill Cutler is developing a new paradigm for decision making and public policy, yesterday I had an epiphanal moment in better understanding the relationships among society, energy, nature, economics and science. The special insights were provided in a lecture at USF by Charles A.S. Hall. http://www.esf.edu/EFB/hall/

Hall is in the intellectual tradition of M. King Hubbert, Cutler Cleveland, Robert Kaufmann, Robert Herendeen, Robert Ayres , Colin Campbell and Jean Leherrere.

Hall argues that to understand EROI, the energy return on investment for any human activity we need to apply this key relationship. It is the most important defining issue of the future.

Energy delivered to society

EROI = __________________________

Energy put into that activity

Unfortunately this key relationship has been submerged by the increasing dominance of economic cost-benefit analysis.

There are limits to nature’s energy resources. (K. Boulding and H.T. Odum). We need to understand that our dependence on fossil fuel is suicidal. In terms of EROI, the following figures are sobering:

· In 1930 U.S. got 100 barrels of oil back for each barrel invested in seeking it

(EROI = 100:1)

· In 1970 about 25 for 1

· In 1990s about 11 to 18 for one

· Much less for finding new oil (EROI = 3:1??)

The energy pie is getting smaller at a very rapid rate while the hunger of mankind, especially newly developing economies such as China, is increasing at exponential rates.

So we need to make a major paradigm shift in understanding where wealth comes from. It is from Nature, and not primarily from capital or labor. Hall labels this new paradigm “Neophysiocrats” and is articulated in the works of Cleveland, Kaufmann, Gowdy, Krall, and Klitgaard.

The tragedy of our time is that economics has trumped science:

· Today two thirds of U.S. energy comes from oil (nearly two thirds imported) and gas, most of rest from coal

· New sources (except nuclear) remain trivial and are decreasing as %

· Neoclassical economics, including especially monetary cost-benefit analysis, has become the overwhelming choice to make public decisions.

· These ideas have become conflated with the anti-government conservative agenda

· “Let the markets make all decisions” economics has replaced science and any concern for limits to growth. Our patters of consumption are growing daily.

However:

· Oil supply is increasingly limited to a few giant fields, with 10% of all production coming from just four fields and 80% from fields discovered before 1970.

· Even finding a field the size of Ghawar in Saudi Arabia, by far the world's largest and said to have another 125bn barrels, would only meet world demand for about 10 years.

So what are our present options? Hall suggests:

· Fund windmills and certain solar

· Don’t count on Hydrogen, given the energy requirements to pull apart those hydrogen atoms (thermodynamics)

· Go nuclear big time (but not enough Uranium and Chinese have bought it anyway)

· Need Federal leadership

· Take seriously Haubberts observation that ““Our ignorance is not so vast as our failure to use what we know”

· Train our young people in an economics that is real and based on science

The key is to see Nature as our source of economic value for the future of our human experiment. If we continue to live the illusion that cost-benefit economics and the market will provide for energy alternatives, we misunderstand the relationship between technology and science. Technology in the service of bad economic theory will only dig our hole deeper, increase the gap between the haves and the have nots and lead to a dimming of our lights and our civilization.

Merle

0 Comments:

Post a Comment

<< Home